All Inclusive Caribbean Resort? or All Inclusive Caribbean Cruise?

Going on my honeymoon in Dec 2011 or Jan 2012. My husband wants to go on a cruise to the Caribbean (eastern) and I really want to go to an all-inclusive resort? I have asked this questions in the search box and everyone keeps saying a cruise is better for a honeymoon but why? Cruises, techincally, are not all-inclusive, you still have to pay for your drinks, excursions, and all the hidden luxuries? Why is an all-inclusive resort not a better choice? Thanks in advance.

Source: Honeymoon! Cruise or all-inclusive resort? | discountcruisesdeal.com

A view from a room in Playa del Carmen, in eastern tip
of Mexico facing the Caribbean Sea.
Photo from http://www.flickr.com/photos/trinity/

Your plan to go for an all inclusive vacation from New Jersey to the Caribbean, may have those questions as well.

What do you think your choice would be? An all-inclusive resort? or an all-inclusive cruise to the Caribbean?

Here's how an all-inclusive resort may look like ...

Couples Negril Jamaica
Photo from http://www.flickr.com/photos/danellesheree/

Then, here's how an all-inclusive cruise may look like ...

A happy memory of a Royal Caribbean Cruise in 2008.
Photo from http://www.flickr.com/photos/mil8/

Make a wise choice and ... happy vacationing!